PRINT VS FOREVER

New York prints its public documents, then prints them again, forever. There is a cheaper way to keep them: pay once, store permanently, hold the keys. Move the sliders. The math is live.

Keep it forever, once24¢
Print it, one cycle$87,500.00
Print it, ten cycles$875,000.00

Forever = permanent public storage with the copy payable once, upfront (about $48.31 per gigabyte at November 2026 prices, see receipts). Print = pages × copies × the per-page rate, and it recurs every cycle because paper does not survive the cycle.

The board

What New York buys todayPrint, recurringForever, once
The poll-worker manual, reprinted for tens of thousands of workers every cycle estimate: worker count commonly cited≈ $87,500 every cycle≈ 24¢ once (the 5 MB master)
A terabyte: everything the Board of Elections has ever published, on permanent public storage scale is illustrativedoes not apply, paper cannot do this≈ $49,500 once, about 1.1% of one year's absentee-ballot contract
Legally mandated newspaper notices before every general election (NY Election Law § 4-120), which the state's own election board calls "outdated and costly"recurring ad rates, every cycle, then the paper is trashpennies once, public address anyone can check, forever
Context: the BOE's FY2026 budget is $146.7M; the current "Printed Election Supplies" bid is estimated at about $6.9M (estimate until awarded); the 2020 contract to produce and distribute absentee ballots was $4.6M, and it recurs annually. One year of that contract would buy about 93 TB of permanent storage, over 90 copies of everything, forever.

How forever works

You do not rent this storage and you do not renew it. A one-time fee funds a permanent copy on a public network with a tamper-evident receipt, and anyone can verify the document at its address, any year, from any phone. The same page that prices it is the demo: the storage behind this site is live today.

Receipts

  1. Arweave price, one-time: live quotes probed from arweave.net on 2026-11-01 (1 AR = $3.08): 1 GB = $48.31, 5 MB = about 24¢. Calculator uses $48.31/GB with a small-document floor. arweave.net
  2. $87,500 manual row: 50 pages × 35,000 workers × 5¢/page. The 5¢ page rate is a conservative working rate; 35,000 poll workers is commonly cited, not confirmed. vote.nyc
  3. $4.6M absentee-ballot contract: Phoenix contract to produce and distribute absentee ballots, May 2020. NPR
  4. $6.9M printed-supplies bid: NYC procurement listing bid #2600039, "Printed Election Supplies", estimate until awarded.
  5. $146.7M BOE budget: NYC Council FY2026 Budget Overview, Board of Elections. council.nyc.gov
  6. The print mandate and the state's own words: NY Election Law § 4-118 and § 4-120 require newspaper notices; the NYS Board of Elections 2026 legislative packet (item 26-05) proposes ending certified-results print legal ads as "outdated and costly". § 4-120 · NYSBOE 2026 packet
  7. The storage is real: permanent upload door live since October 2026. upload.bitty.cat